Fide AI

Evaluation independence and reporting

Payment buys the work, not the answer.

Effective · October 30, 2026

Fide produces evidence to help people and institutions judge AI systems under stated conditions. Private evaluations support internal decisions. Public assessments give readers findings they can inspect and challenge, without sponsor approval. We state our role, who paid, what we examined and what the evidence can support.

Agree the audience and rights before work begins.

Every arrangement requires honest conclusions. Publication rights and the relationship to the system determine what the work can credibly claim. A private fee includes no public report or automatic research reuse.

Private evaluations

Candid findings for agreed internal recipients and permitted advisers. Confidentiality does not give the customer control over conclusions or imply endorsement. Publication, research reuse, aggregation and training require their own explicit rights.

Restricted work

Feasibility, research, improvement or embedded work with specified reporting limits. Any permitted public description explains those limits and Fide’s actual role; it cannot imply unrestricted independent scrutiny.

Public independent assessments

Fide retains the right to publish supported methods, findings and limitations without participant approval. Bounded review permits factual corrections and narrowly defined privacy, confidentiality and security protections. It cannot veto unfavorable findings or indefinitely delay publication.

State the role behind the findings.

Public availability does not establish independence. Each report identifies Fide’s relationship to the assessed system.

Independent assessment
Fide defines the methods and retains its judgment, with qualified assessors, relevant conflicts addressed and reporting rights established.
Criteria conformance
We check behavior against stated policies or other customer/provider criteria. Those supplied criteria limit the assessment’s independence; meeting them does not establish their adequacy.
Collaborative validation
We measure customer work we materially helped design or implement, with that involvement stated. The assessment is not an independent opinion.
Collaborative research
We investigate a shared question with explicit contributions, evidence rights and control of scientific conclusions.
Development and implementation
We help build or improve a system. Development tests do not provide independent assurance of that work.

Fide’s own checks of what it builds are development validation, never an independent opinion; independent assessment of Fide-built solutions comes only from qualified outside assessors. Our assessment of customer work we materially helped design or implement is collaborative validation, never an independent opinion. A different internal reviewer or disclosure alone does not establish independence. Using Fide’s evaluation tools alone does not make us the system’s builder. We reassess our role as the work changes and disclose material advice affecting later findings.

Safeguards across every engagement.

Payment and judgment

Fees pay for agreed work and never depend on favorable findings. Fide controls its analysis, conclusions and limitations within the agreed scope. Payment and prospects for future business cannot determine our findings, severity judgments or recommendations. Receiving agreed findings never depends on buying additional services.

Conflicts and relationships

We disclose material relationships and funding dependencies and recuse conflicted personnel. Related-entity work requires independent oversight and non-conflicted signoff. Private disclosures reach authorized recipients; public findings and claims carry public disclosures. This protects confidentiality while keeping conflicts visible to those relying on the work. Separate companies under common ownership do not automatically establish independence.

Privacy and care

We agree permitted data use and protections before testing, minimize sensitive data and apply safeguards appropriate to the people affected, including children. Access grants no automatic research, aggregation or training rights.

Human responsibility

Our findings inform human judgment. Responsible people and institutions decide whether, where and how to deploy AI in light of their mission, obligations and the evidence.

What a public independent assessment requires.

  1. Advance rights to publish supported methods, findings and limitations without participant approval.
  2. No material Fide design or implementation role in the assessed subject matter.
  3. Qualified, non-conflicted reviewers with clear responsibility for methods, decisions and publication.
  4. Review limited to defined grounds, deadlines and an identified decision-maker.
  5. A public account of the methods, operating conditions, evidence, findings and limitations.

We register commissioned public assessments when work begins, stating the system, who commissioned it, scope and expected release window or trigger. A documented security reason may delay registration until the report or status notice. Every commissioned, registered or publicly announced public project receives a report, limitations account or status notice, including adverse, inconclusive or discontinued work.

We secure lasting rights to publish authorized evidence, subject to agreed protections. Neither party can turn public work private after seeing the results. We may initiate research using lawful public access and publication rights without the evaluated organization’s approval.

Each public report opens with a statement of its operating conditions and includes an AEF-1 checklist with unmet conditions. We disclose funding, conflicts, access requested, received and denied, material advice and pressures, reviewer affiliations, and review/redaction powers and their use. Methods, material assumptions and worldviews, human validation, uncertainty and disclosure limits accompany the findings. We explain how withheld evidence affects scrutiny and narrow or decline unsupported conclusions. A checklist establishes neither accreditation nor scientific validity.

AEF-1 sets out minimum operating conditions for independent third-party AI evaluations.

Private reports state their operating conditions to agreed recipients. All findings stay within the tested scope and available evidence. Public claims need evidence that can be verified within agreed data protections.

Fide does not currently offer audits; an evaluation report alone confers neither certification nor blanket deployment approval.

Public assessments and reports →

Review can correct facts and protect sensitive details.

The evaluated party can identify factual errors, provide counterevidence, flag protected information and submit a short response alongside the report. Review cannot veto findings, rewrite our conclusions or create an indefinite delay. Reputational discomfort is not a redaction ground.

Only genuinely disputed sensitive material is held; unaffected findings proceed. Fide decides whether withheld evidence requires a narrower conclusion and explains material limits. Responsible disclosure protects sensitive details. It creates no general right to publish private evidence.

Review and responsible-disclosure defaults

These are negotiating defaults for commissioned public work, agreed before testing. Deadlines override neither law nor agreed protections and are not universal service guarantees.

Ordinary review: five business days
Specific factual or protected-information objections. Findings without protected material proceed after the window, with corrections or material disagreement represented fairly.
Sensitive disputes: five business days after ordinary review
A non-conflicted decision-maker resolves genuinely disputed sensitive passages; unaffected findings proceed. Repeated objections do not restart the clock without material new information.
Security: bounded responsible disclosure
Initial delay up to 30 calendar days. Justified extensions need an authorized scientific/security decision and reassessment at least every 30 days. For publicly available systems, withholding vulnerability information ends within 60 days after provider notice unless treated as an information hazard. Law, privacy and source protections remain; no automatic release of exploit details is promised.

Vulnerabilities that cannot reasonably be fixed and are likely to be exploited may require minimal redaction as information hazards. Safe findings or status notices proceed where lawful. A commissioner other than the evaluated party may object only to disclosure of its own protected information.

Corrections and independence concerns.

Send the report, version and evidence for your concern. Qualified, non-conflicted reviewers assess it separately from commercial negotiations. We explain material corrections visibly and qualify or retract unsupported conclusions. Historical versions remain marked unless privacy, security or law requires removal.

Accurate references and clearly identified criticism need no Fide approval. We correct misleading claims about our involvement while protecting confidential information. Retesting a changed system is separate work.

Report a correction or policy concern →

Opens an email to [email protected]. Send a non-sensitive summary first; arrange secure transfer before sharing protected evidence.